Interrogating Young Suspects I

The present volume contains the results of the first part of the research project 'Protecting Young Suspects in Interrogations’: a legal comparative study into existing legal procedural safeguards for juvenile suspects during interrogation in the five selected Member States.
Michele Panzavolta, Dorris de Vocht, Marc Van Oosterhout, Miet Vanderhallen
Maastricht Series in Human Rights
book | published | 1st edition
May 2015 | xxiv + 428 pp.


ISBN 9781780682990

When you check this box, you will be subscribed to the series. If you subscribe to the series, each new volume will automatically be sent to you. You can only cancel your subscription after having received two consecutive volumes.


The vulnerability of juvenile suspects concerns all phases of proceedings but is probably greatest during interrogations in the investigation stage. These early interrogations often constitute the juvenile suspects’ first contact with law enforcement authorities during which they are confronted with many difficult questions and decisions. Therefore, the juvenile suspect should already at this stage be provided with an adequate level of procedural protection.

The research project ‘Protecting Young Suspects in Interrogations’ underlying this volume, sprung from the observation that the knowledge of the existing level of procedural protection of juvenile suspects throughout the European Union is limited. More specifically, there is very little knowledge of what actually happens when juvenile suspects are being interrogated. The research project aims to fill at least part of this gap by shedding more light on the existing procedural rights for juveniles during interrogations in five EU Member States representing different systems of juvenile justice (Belgium, England and Wales, Italy, Poland and the Netherlands). In doing so, it intends to identify legal and empirical patterns to improve the effective protection of the juvenile suspect. The project is a joint effort of Maastricht University, Warwick University, Antwerp University, Jagiellonian University and Macerata University in cooperation with Defence for Children and PLOT Limburg.

The present volume contains the results of the first part of the research project: a legal comparative study into existing legal procedural safeguards for juvenile suspects during interrogation in the five selected Member States. The country reports incorporated in this volume provide for an in-depth analysis of the existing rules and safeguards applicable during the interrogation of juvenile suspects. On the basis of these findings a transversal analysis is carried out in the final chapter, which is dedicated to the identification of common patterns with a view to harmonising the systems and improving the protection of juvenile suspects’ rights. Part 2 and 3 of the research project (empirical research consisting of observations of recorded interrogations and focus group interviews) and a final merging of the legal and empirical findings resulting in a proposal for European minimum rules and best practice on the protection of juvenile suspects during interrogation will be published in a separate, second volume (‘Interrogating Young Suspects: Procedural Safeguards from an Empirical Perspective’).

The book is intended for academics, researchers, practitioners and policy-makers working in the area of juvenile justice and interrogation.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents (p. 0)

Chapter 1. Introduction (p. 1)

Michele Panzavolta, Dorris de Vocht

Chapter 2. Balancing the Need for Protection and Punishment of Young Delinquents. Country Report Belgium (p. 51)

Marc Van Oosterhout

Chapter 3. Ensuring ‘Appropriate’ Protections for Young Suspects. Country Report England and Wales (p. 123)

Jacqueline Hodgson, Vicky Kemp

Chapter 4. Between Respecting ‘Traditional’ Safeguards and Modern Needs of Protecting Juveniles. Country Report Italy (p. 179)

Chapter 5. Protecting Juvenile Suspects in a Pedagogical but Punitive Context. Country Report the Netherlands (p. 241)

Marc Van Oosterhout, Dorris de Vocht

Chapter 6. Procedural Complexity within a Welfare Approach. Country Report Poland (p. 313)

Chapter 7. Transversal Analysis of the Country Reports. General Patterns (p. 369)

Michele Panzavolta, Dorris de Vocht

Annex: Template Country Report. Young Suspects in Interrogations (p. 419)

About the series:

Maastricht Series in Human Rights

The Maastricht Series in Human Rights facilitates and supports research in the field of human rights at the Maastricht Centre for Human Rights of Maastricht University’s Faculty of Law. The research is interdisciplinary, with a focus on public international law, criminal law and social sciences.

Volume in the series have been peer reviewed under the responsibility of the Board of the Centre. The Series is published under the editorial supervision of Professor Menno Kamminga and Professor Fons Coomans.

With a subscription to the series you enjoy a 15% discount on each volume!

More about this series