Morally Sensitive Issues and Cross-Border Movement in the EU

Within the European Union there is considerable diversity in morally sensitive issues like legal recognition of same-sex relationships or reproductive matters, such as abortion, assisted human reproduction (AHR) and surrogacy.
Author(s):
Nelleke Koffeman
Series:
School of Human Rights Research Series
Volume:
72
book | published | 1st edition
November 2015 | xx + 726 pp.

Paperback
€110.-


ISBN 9781780683492


If you subscribe to the series, each new volume will automatically be sent to you. You can only cancel your subscription after having received two consecutive volumes.

Details

Within the European Union there is considerable diversity in morally sensitive issues like legal recognition of same-sex relationships or reproductive matters, such as abortion, assisted human reproduction (AHR) and surrogacy. States generally expressly claim recognition of such diversity and it is explicitly respected at European level, even though the (implicit) influence of European law is increasingly visible in these areas.

Cross-border movement within the EU adds a new dimension to this complex picture. It implies that States are increasingly confronted by (the consequences of) one another’s regimes. For example, same-sex couples residing in one EU Member State claim recognition of their marriage concluded in another Member State, or women from Member States with restrictive abortion regimes resort to States with more liberal regimes. This research explores this cross-border dimension, identifies a number of pressing questions and provides insight into the interests that are at stake in such situations.

This volume firstly investigates what – if any – standard-setting is in place in three national jurisdictions (Ireland, Germany and the Netherlands) as well as in the relevant European jurisdictions (EU law and the ECHR) in respect of reproductive matters and legal recognition of same-sex relationships, and how this has developed over time. This analysis inter alia provides insight into what considerations and interests play or have played a role in legislative debates and case-law, in what respects the regimes studied differ, and how European law has influenced national standard-setting. It furthermore provides the necessary basis for the subsequent analysis of how the relevant jurisdictions respond to cross-border movement in these areas and how they interact. While, for example, States sometimes appear to ward off cross-border movement in these areas to protect their national moral standards, in other situations they choose to – or are obliged under European law to – accommodate such mobility in order to protect the interests of vulnerable parties involved. This research thereby observes and clarifies the dynamics in decision-making regarding these issues, analysing and explaining how various areas and levels of law interact.

This volume has been written as a PhD thesis by Nelleke Koffeman (Europa Institute, Leiden University), supervised by Prof. Dr. Janneke Gerards (Radboud University) and Prof. Dr. Rick Lawson (Leiden University).

Chapters

Table of Contents (p. 0)

INTRODUCTION

Chapter 1. Introduction (p. 1)

CASE STUDY I – REPRODUCTIVE MATTERS

Chapter 2. ECHR (p. 15)

Chapter 3. EU (p. 73)

Chapter 4. Germany (p. 139)

Chapter 5. Ireland (p. 199)

Chapter 6. The Netherlands (p. 257)

Chapter 7. Conclusions Case Study I (p. 317)

CASE STUDY II . LEGAL RECOGNITION OF SAME-SEX RELATIONSHIPS

Chapter 8. ECHR (p. 345)

Chapter 9. EU (p. 403)

Chapter 10. Germany (p. 469)

Chapter 11. Ireland (p. 531)

Chapter 12. The Netherlands (p. 565)

Chapter 13. Conclusions Case Study II (p. 607)

CONCLUSIONS

Chapter 14. Conclusions (p. 629)

Executive Summary (p. 649)

Executive Summary (in Dutch) (p. 657)

Bibliography (p. 667)

Table of Cases (p. 701)

Index (p. 715)

Curriculum Vitae (p. 723)

About the series:

School of Human Rights Research Series

The School of Human Rights Research Series traces the history and the development of the human rights movement. Through its distinctive interdisciplinary approach, the series provides a powerful insight into recent developments in the field of human rights - their promotion, implementation and monitoring. Anyone directly involved in the definition, study, implementation, monitoring, or enforcement of human rights will find this series an indispensable reference tool.

The world famous School of Human Rights Research is a joint effort by human rights researchers in the Netherlands. Its central research theme is the nature and meaning of international standards in the field of human rights, their application and promotion in the national legal order, their interplay with national standards, and the international supervision of such application.
Editorial Board of the Series: Prof. dr. J.E. Goldschmidt (Utrecht University), Prof. dr. D.A. Hellema (Utrecht University), Prof. dr. W.J.M. van Genugten (Tilburg University), Prof. dr. F. Coomans (Maastricht University), Prof. dr. P.A.M. Mevis (Erasmus University Rotterdam), Dr.J.-P. Loof (Leiden University) and Dr. O.M. Ribbelink (Asser Institute).

With a subscription to the series you enjoy a 15% discount on each volume!

More about this series